TO: Mr. Steven Perry,
Pro Football Hall
of Fame
FROM: Thomas C. Ferry
SUBJECT:
Johnny Robinson, Safety,
Dallas Texans/Kansas City Chiefs 1960-1972
Greetings, Mr. Perry:
The induction of Dallas Texans/Kansas City Chiefs safety
Johnny Robinson into the Pro Football Hall
of Fame is a long-overdue
honor that needs to come to pass.
As Lawrence Taylor is said to have re-defined
the position he played, it has also been claimed by
those who should know that Johnny Robinson re-defined
the position of safety. Opposing quarterbacks went to
great lengths to avoid throwing the ball into his
territory. Despite this, he ended his career with 57
interceptions, which currently has him tied for 9th
place all-time among former defensive backs.
In a comparison with all former defensive backs
who who had at least 40 interceptions in their careers,
27 players fell into this category, including Robinson.
Out of these 26 other players, 14 that began and ended
their careers AFTER Robinson have already been inducted
into the Hall of Fame. Out of
these 14, Robinson has more career interceptions than 9
of them. He
has more career interceptions than 13 of the 26
players on the total list. ALL 13 OF THESE PLAYERS ARE
IN THE HALL OF FAME.
Robinson played for 12 years; however, his first
two seasons were spent playing offense, which means he
spent 10 years at safety. Take his 57 interceptions and
divide that by his 10 years at safety, and you have an
average of 5.7 interceptions per season. Out of the
other 26 players on the list, HIS SEASONAL AVERAGE IS
HIGHER THAN ALL BUT TWO, those being Bobby Boyd of the
Baltimore Colts (6.3) and Jack Christiansen of the
Detroit Lions.(5.8) Faced with this statistic, a case
could be argued that Johnny Robinson IS THE THIRD MOST
EFFECTIVE PASS INTERCEPTOR OF ALL TIME!
20 of the 26 players on this list,
other than Robinson, are in
the Hall of Fame. 6 of these
20 never were on a championship team, which seems, based
on available evidence, to be an important credential in
boosting one's chances for Hall of
Fame consideration. I define a
championship team as:
(1) Any pre-merger AFL or NFL Championship
team; (2) Any post-merger AFC or NFC Championship
team; or (3) Any Super Bowl
winning team (which would
supersede a conference or league title, and not count as
an extra championship). 5 of
these 6 players who were never
on a championship team also have fewer career
interceptions than Robinson. 3 others
of the 20 were on FEWER championship teams than
Robinson, who was a member of 3.
[Webmaster's note:
Pre-merger league championships were just that.
The Packers won two championships in 1966: NFL and
World. Similarly, the Chiefs won two championships
in 1969: AFL and World, so Robinson played on
four championship teams. AFC and NFC
championships are not equivalent to league
championships.]
There were 24 players chosen in the 10-year
history of the American Football League as the
all-time best players at
their positions. One of the
two safeties was Johnny Robinson, who
I believe was chosen not just for his
interception total but for his toughness and endurance.
Johnny Robinson preferred the competition and
challenge of playing safety versus
playing offense. In his own words: "Somebody on
the offense can blow a play and it isn't a disaster. If
a defensive back goofs, it's 6 points. When you know
that, it's an advantage. You never let up."
Johnny Robinson "never let up."
In a 12-year career comprising 176 total games
(168 regular season and 8 postseason), Robinson missed
only 4. Two games in particular are illustrative of his
grit. In the 1969 AFL Championship Game vs. the Oakland
Raiders, Robinson broke several ribs in a third quarter
sideline collision. Despite great pain, he continued to
play. Through the remainder of the game, the Chiefs
intercepted 4 Oakland passes as the Raiders went to the
air in an attempt to overcome the Chiefs' lead. None of
the passes were intercepted by Robinson---an indication
that despite the pain of his injury, he was still
performing at a level that induced the Raiders into
avoiding throwing passes into his area.
In the Super Bowl a
week later, Robinson insisted on playing. As one of
the 20
players who were a part of the AFL from beginning to
end, he was determined to see the job through in what
was the biggest game he and his team had ever played. A
thoracic surgeon deadened the pain in his ribs and
occupied a place on the Chiefs' bench throughout the
game. Deadened ribs notwithstanding, there was always
the danger that a collision could cause the ribs to
puncture a lung. Playing anyway, Robinson intercepted a
pass and recovered a fumble. On the
fumble recovery,
he was upended as he picked up the ball, which could
have caused the injury to become dangerously severe. He
survived the hit, and his team went on to score their
ultimate victory. To quote a famous book title, a
"profile in courage," not to mention toughness and
determination.
For the era in which Robinson played,
statistics for tackles made
are not readily available all these years later, but he
made his share. In a 1967 game against the
Raiders, he made 17. Some men who have played the
secondary positions over the years have a reputation,
deserved or not, for avoiding collisions whenever
possible. The fact that Robinson spent his first two
years as a running back, coupled with the aforementioned
examples, demonstrate that fear of contact was not
anything he was ever accused of; conversely, he was
known as a hard-nosed, complete football player.
The following is a most worthy resumé
of Johnny Robinson's football achievements---
-Member of Chiefs
team which won more games than any other in the 10-year
history of the AFL.
[Webmaster's note:
Since Robinson was the only member of
the Texans/Chiefs to play all ten years, he won more
games than any other AFL player.]
-Chiefs had a
35-1-1 record in games where he intercepted at least one
pass.
-Critical timely
interception in 1966 AFL Championship Game turned what
could have been a halftime
tie into a 10-point Chiefs advantage, as they went on to
defeat the Buffalo Bills and earn a trip to the
first Super Bowl.
-Led AFL in
interceptions in 1966 (10).
-Led NFL in
interceptions in 1970 (10).
-Member of AFL
Championship team 3 times.
-Member of team
which won Super Bowl 4.
-AFL All-Star
selection 6 times.
-First-Team
All-AFL 5 times. (All-AFL and AFL All-Star selections
being two separate honors, the
same as NFL All-Pro and Pro Bowl selections)
-Second-Team
All-AFL 2 times.
-First-Team
NFL All-Pro 1970.
-NFL Pro Bowl
selection 1970.
-Second-Team
NFL All-Pro 1971.
-First-Team
member of Kansas City Chiefs All-Time Team.
-Member of Chiefs
Hall of Fame.
-Member of
www.remembertheafl.com
AFL Hall of Fame.
-First-Team
member of the
AFL's All-Time Team.
-Member of
Pro Football's
Team of The Decade of the
1960s (a combination of AFL and NFL
players--this honor bestowed by an organization that as
of yet has not seen fit, paradoxically, to
award him the ULTIMATE honor!)
57 appears to be a mostly unlucky number when it
comes to Hall of Fame
recognition. Robinson and 4 other players are tied with
this number of interceptions for their careers.
Out of these 5, only one (Mel Blount of the Pittsburgh
Steelers) is in the Hall of
Fame. It appears that other than the fact that Mel
Blount was indeed one of the greatest players of all
time, he also benefited greatly from the modern
post-merger interest in the game, which has been
characterized by massive media attention for, and
promotion of, the NFL. Although Blount's career ended
over a decade after Robinson's, he has been in the Hall
of Fame for 20 years, ever
since his first year of eligibility. Easier, it seems,
for younger selectors who have either no memory or faint
memory of the AFL and the early years following the
merger, to focus attention on more recent players who
have the advantage of greater media publicity and
familiarity. Easier, perhaps, than taking the time and
going to the effort of doing the research necessary to
determine that deserving players of Robinson's caliber
have been overlooked and should perhaps be near the head
of the line for the honor.
Larry Wilson of the St. Louis Cardinals played
the same position as Robinson in the same hard-nosed
manner for roughly the same time period (1960-1972) and
is a member of the same Team of
The 1960s Decade as
Robinson. He had 5 fewer interceptions in his career and
played on no championship teams, in comparison to
Robinson's 3. He was inducted into the Hall
of Fame his first year of
eligibility. Deserving of the honor? No question he was.
The overriding question here is---after the
statistics that have been cited, the honors mentioned
that have been
bestowed, the comparisons that have been made
with peers---WHY HAS JOHNNY ROBINSON BEEN OVERLOOKED FOR
HALL OF FAME INDUCTION FOR OVER 30 YEARS?
The NFL has always been image and PR conscious,
and likes it when its current (and former) players
uphold what are generally perceived as high standards of
virtue.
For many years since his retirement, Johnny
Robinson has operated a home for troubled boys in
Louisiana. This is right in line with the NFL's public
service credo of being willing to give back to the
community. It is also an undertaking, if one were to ask
the man, that might well prove to be one of selfless
giving that he is even prouder of than the many
achievements he had in his football career. Yet another
opportunity for the NFL to shine a positive light on
itself by spotlighting yet another example of one of its
former players being an upstanding, solid, contributing
citizen, by promoting the cause Robinson cares so much
about and one of which the NFL seems to care
greatly---troubled youth. A Hall of
Fame induction, and the attendant publicity that goes
with it, is a great opportunity for this.
In sum, 3 questions---
-If Johnny
Robinson does not have Hall of
Fame credentials, WHO DOES?
-Why has Johnny
Robinson been overlooked for Hall of
Fame induction for so many years?
-How soon
will the Hall rectify this
"gross" oversight?
I am interested in answers other than
statements of how "this
is up to the Retired Players
Selection Committee", and how there are "only so many
slots open" for players after so many years. I'm
interested in answers other than the Hall
oOf Fame's rules governing
induction. You could get
together a special committee to study the problem of
overlooked former AFL (and some NFL) players, and
suspend whatever the current rules are for several years
until a little more equity is achieved. This certainly
will not harm the Hall of
Fame's high standards, and in my opinion, would only
enhance its esteem and prestige among the players and
the fans who support and enjoy it.
The standards for entry into the Pro Football
Hall of Fame should be high.
When the Hall first opened, a
larger than normal class of honorees was enshrined,
to catch up with the history of the game.
Similarly, it is long past time to take the AFL
into higher consideration. Pro football is much larger
than it was when the Hall first opened, and although as
part of the merger agreement, the AFL's stars and
records were officially given recognition, it was still
many years after the merger
that the AFL
began to get its due. At the
same time, deserving NFL players from the pre-merger
days now had to make room for some of their AFL peers,
and some of them have been overlooked. (Jerry Kramer of
the Green Bay Packers is one big example)
I believe it is long past time to amend, even if
only temporarily, the enshrinement rules, to once again
allow the history of the game to catch up
proportionately with the number of players worthy of
induction.
It is hard to conceive that of all the thousands
of men who have played pro football in the past 90
years, only slightly over 200 are worthy of Hall
of Fame induction to this
point.
Whether or not an amendment
of the rules comes about, Johnny Robinson, as
I believe has been proven
here, is every bit as deserving of Hall
of Fame induction as any
player who has ever achieved that honor.
As they say in the NIke commercials---
"JUST DO IT!!"
Thank you for your time and consideration of this
matter. I would like to hear
your thoughts and suggestions.
Sincerely,
Thomas C. Ferry
Virginia Beach, VA.
nospam.Thomas.C.Ferry@att.net